In a recent conversation with Dr. Carolyn Dean, medical doctor, naturopath, and leading magnesium expert, I discovered the important relationship between magnesium and bone health. Dr. Dean, who has authored over 35 books including The Magnesium Miracle, revealed insights that challenge conventional thinking about magnesium, osteoporosis, osteopenia, and bone density.
Summary: Magnesium for Bone Health
For decades, bone health advice has focused almost exclusively on calcium and vitamin D, but this overlooks a critical piece of the puzzle. In this conversation with magnesium expert Dr. Carolyn Dean, we explore why magnesium, which makes up 60% of the mineral content in your bones, deserves equal attention.
Magnesium builds the collagen scaffolding that calcium bonds to, stimulates bone-building cells (osteoblasts), and prevents excessive bone breakdown. Research shows that combining calcium with magnesium produces significantly better bone density results than calcium alone, yet modern diets often create a dangerous imbalance with 10 times more calcium than magnesium.
Dr. Dean explains the optimal calcium-to-magnesium ratio, the best forms of magnesium supplements for absorption, and why magnesium deficiency—linked to anxiety, depression, muscle cramps, and dozens of other conditions—remains under-diagnosed. If you’re concerned about osteoporosis or osteopenia, understanding magnesium’s foundational role in bone health could be the missing link in your prevention strategy.
Magnesium and Bone Health
Approximately 60% of the magnesium in your body is located in your bones.(1) Yet when healthcare providers discuss bone composition, they typically focus almost exclusively on calcium and phosphorus, with magnesium barely getting a mention.
“If a calcium researcher doesn’t look at magnesium, they’re missing the whole picture,” Dr. Dean emphasizes.
So why does this matter? Because magnesium isn’t a passive bystander, it’s actively working to build and maintain them.
How Does Magnesium Affect Bone Health?
Bones are living tissue with a sophisticated architecture. They contain a soft, flexible matrix made of collagen and connective tissue. This is where magnesium plays several critical roles in bone health and formation:
- Building the Foundation: Magnesium helps produce and manufacture collagen, which creates the soft matrix onto which calcium bonds. This scaffolding holds everything together. Without this foundation, calcium has nowhere to properly deposit.
- Stimulating Bone Growth: Research shows that magnesium ions significantly increase osteoblast activity. Osteoblasts are the cells that build new bone. Studies have demonstrated that magnesium induces significant increases in cell viability, alkaline phosphatase activity, and osteocalcin levels of human osteoblasts. All of these stimulatory actions are positively associated with both the concentration of magnesium and the time of exposure.(2) The more magnesium you have and the longer you take it, the more osteoblasts your body produces.
- Preventing Bone Loss: On the flip side, magnesium deficiency results in increased formation of osteoclasts during bone remodeling, the cells that break down bone.(3,4) Elevated osteoclast levels are a threat to bone health and increases the chance of osteopenia and osteoporosis. Why? Because lower magnesium levels can lead to less bone building and more bone breaking.
How Calcium and Magnesium Improve Bone Health
Calcium and magnesium perform an intricate dance within our cells. Here’s how it works:
- Magnesium acts as the gatekeeper, controlling cell mineral ion channels. It allows calcium to enter muscle cells and nerve cells, where calcium creates an action potential, a movement or nerve impulse. Then magnesium opens the channel again, ushering calcium back out.
- This opening and closing mechanism is crucial. Without enough magnesium to guard these gates, calcium floods into cells and causes them to fire continuously until they die. This is what leads to muscle spasms, twitches, and excessive nerve activity
Is Magnesium Good for Osteoporosis?
When asked if magnesium will improve bone density and if it is good for osteoporosis, Dr. Dean’s response focuses on the fundamental architecture of bone:
- Magnesium helps the production of that soft tissue matrix, which takes up 30 to 40% of your bone. The magnesium is important for building the scaffolding onto which the calcium will deposit. Without this scaffolding, you can’t build strong bones, no matter how much calcium you take.
- Research supports this foundational role: a landmark study found that postmenopausal women taking a combination of calcium and magnesium (500mg calcium with 200mg magnesium) experienced an 11% increase in bone mineral density over 9 months, compared to only 0.7% in women who received dietary advice alone.(5)
- Multiple studies have also shown that maintaining an optimal calcium-to-magnesium ratio, typically between 2:1 and 3:1, appears more protective for bone health than focusing on calcium supplementation alone.(6,7)
- As we age, our bones naturally lose hydration and flexibility. That soft tissue matrix collapses and dehydrates, leaving behind brittle calcium carbonate. Maintaining adequate magnesium, along with vitamin C (which helps produce collagen) and other nutrients such as vitamin K and vitamin D, helps preserve that flexibility and resilience.
How Much Calcium and Magnesium for Osteoporosis?
To maintain this delicate balance, Dr. Dean suggests we need roughly equal amounts of calcium and magnesium. She recommends getting:
- About 600 milligrams of calcium from dietary sources like dairy products, leafy greens, and sardines with bones.
- While supplementing with approximately 450 milligrams of magnesium daily (in addition to the 150 milligrams you might get from food).
What Are the Sources of Magnesium?
When it comes to taking magnesium for health and wellness, if somebody goes to their pharmacy or health food store, what would be the best kind to look for?
Liquid Magnesium
Liquid magnesiums are really the best because in a liquid, the mineral compound will dissociate into ions, and that magnesium ion will be absorbed quicker than a magnesium compound like magnesium citrate, glycinate, or chloride. The body has to break down the compound and then it has to dissociate. The liquid is already primed to dissociate.
The trouble with magnesium is that it’s so reactive, it has electrons in the outer ring and will grab onto something else immediately. In the split second that it’s in an ion state, it will go into the cell.
Magnesium Oxide
There hasn’t been enough magnesium research, but magnesium oxide, which most early research was done on and most people have in their formulas, is only 4% absorbed into the blood.
Magnesium Chelates or Magnesium Glycinate?
The magnesium amino acid chelates are more expensive but have higher absorption rates, 40% for magnesium glycinate, for example. However, liquid magnesium can be absorbed at 90-95%.
That’s why I developed a product called ReMag, it’s a stabilized ionic magnesium. The ions are so tiny that they’re absorbed immediately at the cellular level without a laxative effect. You can take therapeutic amounts: 600 to 1,200 milligrams a day in divided doses, without getting diarrhea.
The other thing about magnesium is that it naturally goes to your muscles. That’s where it hangs out. But we have 100 trillion cells in our bodies and about 700 different types of cells, and they all need magnesium. So if you get this ReMag picometer-sized magnesium at a cellular level, it’s going to penetrate all 100 trillion cells.
Best Time of Day to Take Magnesium Supplement?
Is there a best time of day to take magnesium?
It depends on what symptoms you’re trying to treat. If you have heart symptoms during the day, you’d want to take it then. If you want to use it to relax for sleep, then take it in the evening. I prefer taking it in divided doses throughout the day, morning, afternoon, and evening, to keep your body saturated.
Can You Take Too Much Magnesium?
The body will tell you when you’ve had enough magnesium by giving you a laxative effect. It’s really difficult to take too much. The only people who have to be careful are those with kidney failure, which is less than 1% of the population.
In terms of minerals interacting, people always say that magnesium and calcium compete with each other. You can take them together, but I prefer not to because in our diet, we already get so much calcium. If you take more calcium, you push more magnesium out.
Can You Take Too Much Calcium?
Recent research has also challenged the conventional wisdom about high-dose calcium supplementation.
Swedish Calcium Study
There was a study in Sweden showing that if you take 1,500 milligrams of calcium, you can increase your risk of heart attack by 30%. They were looking at the intake of calcium from diet and supplements, about 1,800 milligrams total. That’s very high but not unheard of, because patients tell me they get 1,200 milligrams from their diet and then still supplement.
Our RDA for calcium is 1,200 to 1,500 milligrams, so that’s standard. But no one even knows how much is being absorbed.
New Zealand Calcium Study
Research from New Zealand found that postmenopausal women taking calcium supplements experienced an increased risk of cardiovascular events, raising important questions about the safety of high-dose calcium supplementation.(8) This finding has shifted recommendations considerably.
While U.S. public health departments have traditionally recommended 1,200 to 1,500 milligrams of calcium daily, both the UK and World Health Organization advise just 600 milligrams. Many doctors are now recognizing that the higher amounts may be excessive, and potentially harmful.
Dr. Dean’s advice? “Go for your diet” when it comes to calcium. Get those 600 milligrams from food sources, and focus your supplementation efforts on magnesium instead.
Free Osteoporosis Exercise Course
Summary: Best Vitamins for Bone Health
While this discussion has focused primarily on the calcium-magnesium relationship, Dr. Dean emphasizes that bone health requires a symphony of nutrients working together:
- Magnesium for collagen production and the soft tissue matrix
- Calcium for mineralization (from dietary sources)
- Vitamin K2 to direct calcium to the bones
- Vitamin C to produce collagen
- Collagen itself, to create the flexible framework
Think of bone health as building a house. Calcium is like the bricks, but you need the mortar, the framework, the foundation, and skilled builders to create a structure that will last. Magnesium plays multiple roles in this construction process, it’s not just one material but part of the entire building system.
Nutrition Plan for Treatment of Osteoporosis
Based on Dr. Dean’s expertise, here are actionable nutrition plan for better bone health:
- Get calcium from food: Aim for 600mg daily from dairy, leafy greens, and fish with bones rather than relying on high-dose calcium supplements.
- Supplement with magnesium: Take approximately 450mg of supplemental magnesium daily, in addition to the 150mg you might get from food (total: 600mg).
- Balance is key: Maintain roughly equal amounts of calcium and magnesium for optimal cellular function.
- Be cautious with strontium: If a supplement promises dramatic DEXA improvements, check the label for strontium and consider whether artificially inflated numbers are worth potential risks.
- Think beyond minerals: Ensure adequate vitamin C, vitamin K2, and collagen support for the complete bone health picture.
- Consider the whole system: Bones aren’t just hard, calcified structures, they’re living tissue that needs flexibility, hydration, and proper maintenance.
FAQs: Magnesium and Osteoporosis
Why Is Magnesium Deficiency So Prevalent?
There are many answers to that question. Primarily, magnesium is no longer in the soil, it’s been farmed out. A hundred years ago, we could get 500 milligrams of magnesium from our food. Now we’re lucky to get 150 milligrams. When you consider that magnesium is required to operate 80% of known metabolic functions, we have a real problem. All living cells require magnesium.
Beyond soil depletion, magnesium gets cooked out of food and processed out of food. We have so much stress now, and stress is a real depleter of magnesium. Drugs also deplete magnesium. But what brackets this whole scenario is that we don’t have blood tests that will identify magnesium deficiency. On an electrolyte panel, they don’t even include magnesium. So even though 80% of metabolic functions require magnesium, we don’t test for it, doctors don’t recommend it, and they don’t learn about it in medical school. Everybody is walking around with symptoms of magnesium deficiency.
Why Isn’t Magnesium Deficiency More Well Known?
Even those tests aren’t accurate. The serum magnesium test measures only 1% of total body magnesium, which means only 1% of the body’s magnesium is in the blood. You put your dipstick in the blood and you don’t get an accurate measure. I think that’s why doctors don’t bother testing for it.
There is a magnesium RBC test where they spin out the plasma and measure the magnesium in red blood cells. But here’s the problem: red blood cells don’t contain mitochondria. Mitochondria are where the Krebs cycle occurs, and the Krebs cycle requires six to eight magnesium interfaces to make energy. Since red blood cells don’t have mitochondria, they’re limited in the amount of magnesium they contain. So how is that a good measure?
The research I’m doing is looking at ionized magnesium testing. They have ionized calcium tests, so why don’t they have ionized magnesium tests? That’s what we need to push for—better testing so we can diagnose magnesium deficiency.
Will the Ionized Magnesium Test Be Available in the Near Future?
Hard to say because it’s only in research facilities. The universities I’m working with have ionized testing machines—maybe there are 5,000 operating now. Eventually we’ll get there, but at present, you cannot walk into a lab and get an ionized magnesium test. People have to go by how they feel, and magnesium deficiency symptoms are very easy to pinpoint.
Is There a Link Between Magnesium Deficiency and Anxiety and Depression?
One thing that struck me most when I started your book was how you pointed out that anxiety and depression are symptoms of magnesium deficiency. I hear about these issues constantly—not only in my patients, but in their children and overall in society. Can you speak about the link between magnesium deficiency and anxiety and depression?
When you’re under stress, the adrenal glands pump out a lot of adrenaline, which starts the heart beating faster, makes you clammy, and makes you jittery. Magnesium dampens the expression of ACTH (adrenal corticoid stimulating hormone) that’s made in the anterior pituitary. This hormone stimulates the adrenal glands to release adrenaline. Magnesium attenuates that activity.
Additionally, magnesium, along with vitamin C and B vitamins, is very important for creating adrenaline. When you use up your adrenaline, you need nutrients to make more. When we overstimulate the adrenal glands and get excessive adrenaline, we start palpitating and getting jittery. People think they’re having an anxiety attack when they’re actually having a magnesium deficiency attack.
Regarding depression, when you don’t have enough magnesium to calm your muscles and nerves, problems arise. Magnesium relaxes muscles—it allows calcium to go into a muscle and create an action potential for movement, but then magnesium closes the door and won’t let more calcium in. If there’s not enough magnesium, calcium keeps entering the cell until it activates itself to death. The same thing happens with nerves.
If you get too much calcium, you’re twitching and cramping, which interferes with sleep. If you don’t get good sleep, you wake up in the morning with symptoms that can be misdiagnosed as depression, when it’s actually fatigue from not sleeping properly because you’re magnesium deficient. It’s a terrible vicious cycle.
When you go to a medical doctor with palpitations, anxiety, depression, and fatigue, they put you on antidepressants and anxiolytic drugs instead of asking if you might be magnesium deficient. It’s a very sad state of affairs that we’ve allowed medicine to avoid the use of nutrients or even the research of nutrients to understand how vital they are as co-factors for everything the body does.
Relationship Between Levels of Calcium and Magnesium
I’ve noticed when my clients tell me they have muscle spasms, I’ll ask about their calcium intake versus magnesium intake. You mentioned that if calcium is too high—but are we saying calcium is too high in absolute terms, or relative to the magnesium you’re taking?
It’s relative to magnesium. What’s happened in our society is that we have biological factors that limit our intake of magnesium, we get a laxative effect when we have too much. Parallel to that, we have factors that grab onto calcium, like vitamin D, so we get rid of too much magnesium while we keep grabbing calcium.
This happened ancestrally because humans grew in cultures close to water and the ocean. Ocean water has three times the magnesium compared to calcium. If your diet is mostly from the ocean, you’re getting a lot of magnesium. Calcium was harder to get, you hear about animals traveling hundreds of miles to get to calcium licks. You’d get calcium from bones, for example.
In our society, we somehow got the idea that we needed more calcium. Even orange juice is fortified with calcium. We’re now at a state where we can have a ratio of 10 parts calcium to one part magnesium, which is horrific. That’s what’s calcifying us. Many early researchers on anti-aging said that calcification is the cause of aging. Our arteries get calcified, our joints get calcified. We should be fluid and balanced with enough flexible magnesium compared to rigid calcium.
General Recommendations on Magnesium and Health
Is there anything else you’d like to share regarding general health, wellness, and magnesium?
In my book, The Magnesium Miracle, I identified and listed 65 health conditions, medical conditions, or diseases that could be mistaken for magnesium deficiency. To me, it was amazing: migraines, headaches, choking symptoms, eye twitches, cramping of the jaws, heart palpitations, angina, blood pressure issues, irritable bowel syndrome, constipation, leg cramps—any muscle in the body can cramp up. Even acid reflux: if your stomach is in spasm, you’ll reflux. If you don’t have enough magnesium, you’re not producing stomach acid to digest your food.
If your blood sugar is starting to go off, take magnesium. One of the signs of diabetes is low magnesium. If you take your magnesium, you’re helping about ten different metabolic functions related to the pancreas, the release of insulin, and how insulin helps glucose get into cells before you become insulin resistant.
Also, to digest sugar you use up a lot of magnesium. Glucose and fructose are different—fructose requires twice as much magnesium to digest as glucose. People going into vegan or vegetarian diets tend to eat too much fruit and can get into trouble with mineral deficiencies. I’ve had many vegetarians and vegans say they’re drinking 40 ounces of green drink a day and developed palpitations, insomnia, and cramps. They take some magnesium and get better because they’re basically healthy.
Conclusion
For decades, the bone health conversation has been dominated by calcium and vitamin D, with magnesium relegated to a supporting role, or ignored entirely. But the science tells a different story. With 60% of your body’s magnesium residing in your bones and playing crucial roles in building the very foundation that calcium depends on, it’s time to give this mineral the attention it deserves.
As Dr. Dean’s research and clinical experience demonstrate, strong bones require more than just piling on calcium supplements. They need the right balance of nutrients, with magnesium playing a starring role in creating the flexible, resilient skeletal structure that can support you throughout your life.
The next time someone talks to you about bone health, ask them about magnesium. It might just be the missing piece they’ve been overlooking.
Margaret Martin
Further Readings
References
- Castiglioni S, Cazzaniga A, Albisetti W, Maier JAM. Magnesium and Osteoporosis: Current State of Knowledge and Future Research Directions. Nutrients. 2013;5(8):3022-3033. doi:10.3390/nu5083022
- He LY, Zhang XM, Liu B, Tian Y, Ma WH. Effect of magnesium ion on human osteoblast activity. Braz J Med Biol Res. 2016;49(7):e5257. doi:10.1590/1414-431X20165257
- Belluci MM, Schoenmaker T, Rossa-Junior C, Orrico SRP, de Vries TJ, Everts V. Magnesium deficiency results in an increased formation of osteoclasts. J Nutr Biochem. 2013;24(8):1488-1498. doi:10.1016/j.jnutbio.2012.12.008
- Rude RK, Kirchen ME, Gruber HE, Meyer MH, Luck JS, Crawford DL. Magnesium deficiency-induced osteoporosis in the rat: Uncoupling of bone formation and bone resorption. Magnes Res. 1999;12(4):257-267.
- Abraham GE, Grewal H. A total dietary program emphasizing magnesium instead of calcium. Effect on the mineral density of calcaneous bone in postmenopausal women on hormonal therapy. J Reprod Med. 1990;35(5):503-507.
- Tarco ME, Tucker KL, Bigornia SJ, et al. Association between a Calcium-to-Magnesium Ratio and Osteoporosis among Puerto Rican Adults. J Nutr. 2023;153(6):1823-1832. doi:10.1016/S0022-3166(23)37602-8
- Groenendijk I, van Delft M, Versloot P, van Loon LJC, de Groot LCPGM. Impact of magnesium on bone health in older adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Bone. 2022;154:116233. doi:10.1016/j.bone.2021.116233
- Bolland MJ, Barber PA, Doughty RN, et al. Vascular events in healthy older women receiving calcium supplementation: randomised controlled trial. BMJ. 2008;336(7638):262-266. doi:10.1136/bmj.39440.525752.BE
- Castiglioni S, Cazzaniga A, Locatelli L, Maier JAM. An update on magnesium and bone health. Biometals. 2021;34(4):715-736. doi:10.1007/s10534-021-00305-0
Comments